This sort of came up on the Discord this week, and as somebody who has been watching the French show for the best part of thirty years I would of course be lying if I suggested I had never considered “what about…?” and in fact recently had some ideas playing in my head. So here’s basically an extended version of things I wrote, for better or worse:
- My personal feeling is that doing it closer to the French presentational style opens up the possibility space – I’ve never much liked the idea that it’s just a jumped up outward bound centre even if that’s just what it exactly is really, but there are ways to make it ‘Brit-relatable’. Not really a slam on how we’ve done it before, I think Leslie Grantham becoming increasingly panto was fun. I would work on the assumption that with time constraints Judgement and the Council get ditched, although I’d be open to using elements of them in future series when the French have had a bit of a lean year in terms of new games. Realistically you’re looking at a 90m max show, which is about 65-70m with adverts but I think you could do a decent show with less.
- If Yann Le Gac’s English is good enough, would be perfectly happy for him to reprise his Pere Fouras role. But if we wanted to go down a different route, I’d be well up for a retired Pirate Queen, pitched somewhere between one of the captains from Swashbuckle and Cruella DeVille.
- Host could be anyone provided they’re a) funny and b) a bit world-weary. “Hello and welcome to my little holiday home off the coast of France, which I get to live rent free provided that once a week I chaperone a team of treasure hunters who insist on invading, which I have to say is sometimes REALLY badly timed and annoying.”
- All other Bits of Business – Willy Rovelli, Cyril Gossbo – to be done by Dave Benson-Phillips. This is non-negotiable.
- Format: drop the clock, it’s just a narrative device anyway. Three ’rounds’ of challenges. First two rounds are three “epreuves” and an adventure, third round two cells, two adventures, because adventures. Having the ’rounds’ in advance means P-M can still do the occasional bit of business in delivering them to the host, but it’s not after every game. If the team are doing well PF can find someway to blame/shout at PM.
- Winning earns a key, winning an adventure earns TWO keys. Buying out a prisoner costs one key. One of the adventures must be a riddle – there is no “standard” riddle these days, they all have a hint of danger attached.
- Right, the fun bit – there are 16 keys up for grabs. The first five are used to open the Treasure Room. The team must decide how they want to spend their other ones, either on time (base of 2m, each key spent adding 20secs), or at the Clue Cabinet. They can sacrifice people for keys to unlock more clues, but once they’ve set the clock that’s it.
Also I’ve been desperate to redesign the clue boxes for years and years. Combination locks are so *rubbish* for TV. So here’s a very simple pencil drawing of an idea I’ve been playing with:
Features!
- Six buttons arranged on the front. Push the right one – box opens! Push the wrong one – clue explodes!
- Designed to be eliminatory (“don’t press ‘blue tiger’!” for Tete Cherceuse, for example), or requiring two halves to make a whole (“red” “snake”), or just plain old ‘press that one’!
- Light on top starts flashing at twenty seconds remaining, giving team chance of quick discussion re: let them finish vs just take a guess.
- They might luck out! This is a feature not a bug.
Phew! Well I’m glad I’ve finally got that out of paper even if I’ll look back on it in a few years and wonder what the hell I was thinking that for.
I would prefer, a fuse on the safe with a keypad to type the combination on the side of the box and when time expires, the box explodes really loudly and destroys everything inside it.
50 minutes until the Treasure Chamber gate opens (Phase one, clock is paused for the Cage, end of phase one after 25 minutes, the clock stops again for the judgment hall, clock resumes for phase two and doesn’t stop)
The joker for phase two which can be used once and allow that team member to nominate another person to do the challenge.
The grand escape in case someone is in jail when the 50 minutes expires.
Seven keys required to unlock the gate. (Additional keys add and extra 15 seconds to the Treasure Chamber time)
I would go for a slightly different approach, a much shorter game that can fit into a 1 hour timeslot (46 Minutes with ads). I would also pitch this as a children’s/family show, much like Ultimate Challenge.
– Family teams (a la Crystal Maze USA)
– 10 Challenges overall (No clock necessary, but may be used for key games only)
– 7 Key games for 5 Keys (3rd game always an outdoor adventure), many games adjusted to be about the same difficulty as Ultimate Challenge, so most teams should get 4/5 keys
– No prisoners, they just lose the key if they don’t get out in time (We can’t have the kids sent to prison, right?!)
– 3 Clue games (1st game being a Council duel)
Treasure room – 3:00 Minutes (Minus 10 seconds for each key short, bonus keys exchanged for clue words)
No Prison or Judgement, just a traditional three stage format
Characters: PP, PM, Monique, Master of Darkness
Presentation – Similar to current French show
Host – Take your pick, I personally would have Basil Brush as “Great Uncle Basil” who fills the role of PF and would have similar interactions with PM.
A bit different to be sure, but I feel it would be reasonably realistic, and could be done on a limited budget too. What do you think.
Basil Brush is kind of ingenious.
I’ve just had this idea for a one-off episode where Jacques and Jules are replaced by Melanie and Martina from Funhouse.
LET’S RE-RUN THE FUN…ambule?
“How many keys have you got?”
“One… Two… Three… Four… Five! YYEEEEAAAAAHHHHHH!”